Home > Film > Dreams Come True or Ggumeun Yirueojinda or 꿈은 이루어진다 (2010)

Dreams Come True or Ggumeun Yirueojinda or 꿈은 이루어진다 (2010)

Dreams Come True

It’s always tempting to believe that when any large group of people lives with a problem for a long time, some will grow bored and ignore it — after all, what can relatively powerless individuals do to change the big picture — while the majority will be quietly obsessed with it. As an example, take the situation in Taiwan as it carefully navigates cross-Strait relations with mainland China. According to the latest survey, about three-quarters of the population support an improvement in the relationship with China. Since the problem is not going to go away, most agree that opening lines of discussion is better than beefing up military preparedness and being confrontational. Coming to the Korean peninsula, we have two sovereign states and an Armistice Agreement signed in July 1953, i.e. they are technically still at war. The DMZ is a continual reminder to both sides of the artificial nature of the current situation as the North tests nuclear weapons, fires long-range rockets, sinks the Cheonam, and shells Yeonpyeong Island. The smaller scale attacks are intended to reinforce the credibility of the North’s deterrent power, i.e. the North shows itself willing to risk a resumption of war while the South and its US allies have not retaliated. The exception was that the South did return fire in the Yeonpyeong Island incident. Perhaps they forgot to ask the American’s for permission.

 

How then does the entertainment industry deal with the issue? In Soar into the Sun or R2B: Return to Base or R2B: Riteontu Beyiseu (2012), the South does not fire on the plane from the North that causes moderately extensive damage in Seoul. This matches the passivity over the sinking of the Cheonam and parallels the earlier Joint Security Area (2000) where neither side bends in their antagonism but, apart from exchanging small arms fire across the DMZ, does not escalate into a military engagement. Which brings us to Dreams Come True or Ggumeun Yirueojinda or 꿈은 이루어진다 (2010). The major part of this film is set in a small encampment on the North side of the DMZ. The first squad leader (Lee Sung-Jae) has contrived to pass his obsessional interest in football to the rest of the squad who routinely kick a deflated ball around their muddy compound to fill in the idle hours of their tour of duty. When the South drops a container of goodies, it includes a football. The film is set in 2002 when South Korea jointly hosted the World Cup with Japan. The South is trying a propaganda exercise by building on the known interest in the North. The South wonders whether soldiers in the DMZ could be seduced to cross the line.

The North Koreans support the South

The North Koreans support the South

 

The North’s political officers use the new football as a training exercise in critique with all the soldiers standing up bravely and nicely exposing the weaknesses of the South through metaphors based on the shape, colour and design of the ball. This is a nice moment of satire in what is otherwise a slightly toothless film. I wouldn’t go so far as to say it’s boring but it comes close, largely because it can’t make up its mind what it wants to be. Director Kye Yun-Sik could have made a straight comedy without political overtones, or he could have made a satirical commentary on the way individuals organise their lives to defend against the oppressive nature of the North, or it could have been a straight action drama as political officers try to root out corruption and potential treason in the ranks. But all we get is a nice squad leader who leads his men into a fraternisation with the South, sharing in a wild boar BBQ, and playing football against southern troops in the DMZ. When the North detects an exchange of radio messages and an illegal receiver in operation in the camp, an investigation begins but, somehow, it lacks any sense of menace. Although our squad leader is beaten and the squad members threatened, there’s no intention to show anyone in positive danger. Indeed, the chief investigator, Choi Ji-Hyeon is not unsympathetic to the plight of the squad and covers up the conspiracy. I can’t quite decide what the film-maker’s motives were.

 

Taking a societal overview, there’s a culturally significant unwillingness to criticise others. For one state to interfere in the affairs of another is unacceptable. This trickles down in a general behaviour of deference to elders and those of higher status. So, perhaps, a sustained satire could not have been made. But equally suggesting Northern soldiers might be easily contaminated by decadent southern interests is hardly flattering. Although North Korea now plays in the World Cup tournament, the people are not really engaged internationally. This film would have us believe football is a universal language that transcends culture, politics and geography, but North Korea’s isolationism means few within the North know much about football outside their borders. Perhaps if Dreams Come True or Ggumeun Yirueojinda or 꿈은 이루어진다 had been about half-an-hour shorter, watching it would have felt less of a duty. As it is, I can’t say that I recommend it.

 

About these ads
  1. January 18, 2013 at 1:47 am

    Yes, they did forget to ask American permission. BTW, there’s a huge disconnect between average Americans and, well, the last five or so Secretaries of State; most Americans who knew about the Yeonpyeong Island incident thought the South should have expended a lot more munitions in response.

    Personally, I’ve always thought we should just help South Korea build its own nuclear arsenal and then bring our military home. The South Koreans are big boys. Hell, their civilization is far older than ours–they needed our help once (well, twice), but don’t need us now.

    • January 18, 2013 at 2:10 am

      With the Larry Bond books and this run of movies, it’s been interesting to identify the differences depending on which side controls the narrative. Bond’s support for the South Korean army is a bit grudging and the Korean attitude is “Yankees go home!” Were it not for the rise of China’s military potential, I suspect the Americans would have given up on the Korean and Japanese bases and cut the deficit by reducing the rotations to such distant and unfriendly lands.

      • January 18, 2013 at 2:37 am

        Of course you’re right–we’re still in South Korea because of China. Hopefully an Asian NATO (alliance of Pacific and Southeast Asian countries) will stand up that will allow us to reduce our commitments, but I don’t see that happening soon. Meanwhile China is pushing the Kuril Islands dispute with Japan. I can’t see a war over it–but as a student of history I’ve read about too many stupid wars started for stupid reasons (often unintentionally) to be sanguine about it.

      • January 18, 2013 at 2:49 am

        Actually you’ve missed a few islands out. There are active territorial disputes between mainland China and Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam as everyone argues over fishing rights, oil and gas exploration, and other points of mutual interest. ASEAN has been discussing it but there’s no sign of any co-ordinated policy response at present. It’s every country for itself with the US potentially caught up in some interesting treaty obligations should hostilities break out. It’s a clear road map for a regional war.

      • January 18, 2013 at 3:47 am

        As much as nobody’s thrilled by our being there, I wonder if our treaty commitments are the only thing that has kept the peace over there.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 140 other followers

%d bloggers like this: